Best bourbon under $50?

[model1994]

Kroger today & tomorrow: Buy 6+ and get 30% off. I went to KroGucci, Bloomington's largest location, and bought these. There is quite a bourbon selection but it's mostly typical stock or craft / small batch stuff I've never heard of. Not any VSOP or XO cognac, which was what I was hoping for. Many other liquors and wines. Nonetheless here is what I picked and price after discount:

Bulleit Rye handle $34.97
Michters Rye fifth $29.38
Four Roses Single Barrel fifth $30.07
Basil Hayden fifths (No rye ) $23.77

(for the Hoosiers who can count, not pictured is Tito's handles and loads of wine)

 

[jerrob]

Friday cheers to all.

 

[model1994]

my first time having Four Roses single barrel tonight. it's surprisingly sweet, brown sugar finish is strong. very easy drinking. I didn't know what to expect with 100 proof but this is a winner. Take that for what it's worth, I can't give a proper review as I don't have the most advanced palate for bourbon lol cheers y'all

 

[firecadet613]

Apparently Woodford Double Oaked is in high demand this 30% off sale...

If you see it in your local Kroger on the west side of Indy...let me know!

 

[indykid]

Kroger has that 30% off 6 or more every couple of months.

Four Roses Single Barrel is top on my list, now one opened on my table and one in closet. My current favorite is Four Roses Small Batch Select. Hard to find but a treat when I do.

 

[firecadet613]

Kroger has that 30% off 6 or more every couple of months.

Four Roses Single Barrel is top on my list, now one opened on my table and one in closet. My current favorite is Four Roses Small Batch Select. Hard to find but a treat when I do.

Oh I know, would just like to stash a few more away.... but it appears Kroger is out, not just my local one.

Until next time...

 

[eldirector]

I am finishing a Cardinal Rye at the moment (not literally). Picked up a Bulleit earlier in the week, to nurse over the Holidays. Been on a Rye kick. Sharp enough to slow me down. I drink the sweeter/smoother versions a bit too fast.

Was wanting something "nice" as a gift to myself. I typically stay in the $40 range, but wondering what might be worth about double? There are a lot of $80 choices. Hate to pick something that is no better than a $40 bottle.

 

[model1994]

I am finishing a Cardinal Rye at the moment (not literally). Picked up a Bulleit earlier in the week, to nurse over the Holidays. Been on a Rye kick. Sharp enough to slow me down. I drink the sweeter/smoother versions a bit too fast.

Was wanting something "nice" as a gift to myself. I typically stay in the $40 range, but wondering what might be worth about double? There are a lot of $80 choices. Hate to pick something that is no better than a $40 bottle.

I'm a fan of rye and usually stick to a $50 bottle. Probably the best $50+ common bottle I've had is Angel's Envy. With the Kroger discount it's about $50. Not sure if it's worth $75 or whatever I typically see it at. I'm interested to hear others opinion though. I've been wanting to try the Basil Hayden Rye

 

[jerrob]

If you can find Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye, it's worth the $65ish price tag and is the spiciest rye I've ever drank responsibly.

 

[Creedmoor]

I dont know if this fits in the $50.00 and under as it was a gift. Whats everyones thoughts about it?

 

[jerrob]

If you're gonna drink a Scotch, it may as well be a good one......................and that one will do.
Scotch isn't as "forgiving" as bourbon, I can find a $20 bourbon I'll drink, I'll only use a $20 scotch to start a bonfire.

 

[2AmendTom]

I like the bourbon thread. There are some great options at $50(ish). I think the following are solid picks.

Jefferson’s Reserve
Jefferson’s Ocean (slightly more than $50)
Eagle rare (when you can find it)
Michter’s American Whiskey
Henry McKenna
Woodford Double Oaked

On another note, has anyone ever tried this willet? Be interested to hear your thoughts.

 

[Mr. Habib]

I am finishing a Cardinal Rye at the moment (not literally). Picked up a Bulleit earlier in the week, to nurse over the Holidays. Been on a Rye kick. Sharp enough to slow me down. I drink the sweeter/smoother versions a bit too fast.

Was wanting something "nice" as a gift to myself. I typically stay in the $40 range, but wondering what might be worth about double? There are a lot of $80 choices. Hate to pick something that is no better than a $40 bottle.

Have you tried the Hard Truth Sweet Mash Rye. One of my favorites. About 65 bucks at Krogers, at least here in Bloomington.

 

[Fiddle]

Here is my Kroger haul today!!

 

[cam4usa]

Apparently Woodford Double Oaked is in high demand this 30% off sale...

If you see it in your local Kroger on the west side of Indy...let me know!

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked is my favorite bourbon for sure

 

[rkwhyte2]

Picked this up while I was out. Anyone have any experience with it?

 

[Ballstater98]

Picked this up while I was out. Anyone have any experience with it?
View attachment 242805

It's good. I prefer the 1856.

 

[Hoosierdood]

Looking for opinions...

I've recently been trying some Bourbons, but don't really feel like spending $$$ on a bottle just to find out I don't like it. I like a smooth Bourbon and have found some that I definitely like. What I've found I like, in order of favorites:

1. 1792
2. Woodford Reserve
3. Buffalo Trace
4. Gentleman Jack (I know, not technically a Bourbon)

I've also tried Elijah Craig, and its good, but not as smooth as I'd like. With these selections in mind, what are some recommendations that would be a similar profile?

 

[Ballstater98]

Looking for opinions...

I've recently been trying some Bourbons, but don't really feel like spending $$$ on a bottle just to find out I don't like it. I like a smooth Bourbon and have found some that I definitely like. What I've found I like, in order of favorites:

1. 1792
2. Woodford Reserve
3. Buffalo Trace
4. Gentleman Jack (I know, not technically a Bourbon)

I've also tried Elijah Craig, and its good, but not as smooth as I'd like. With these selections in mind, what are some recommendations that would be a similar profile?

IMHO off the top of my head in no order:
Old Forester
Maker's Mark
Maker's Mark 46
Wild Turkey Longbranch
Weller Special Reserve
New Riff
Blade & Bow
Budget $: Benchmark

 

[Ballstater98]

Of the Benchmark line, this is their highest proof and highest costing.