You think that the homosexual couple are atheists because they are homosexual?I'm sure this will get lost in this HUGE thread...
I am making a call here.
IF the pizza place re-opens...they should put the money they got back for legal defense. In the first 6 months, a gay couple will come in and want them to cater their wedding. Waiting for the impending refusal so they can file a lawsuit.
Thats my call. Throw your bets in on timing of any impending lawsuit.
That said, I think if I were them, I'd cater their event...and do EVERYTHING I could with pizza to put crosses and Christain symbols on every pizza. Would be very easy with pepperoni. Hell, you could probably achieve a similar effect with a butane torch and a sheet metal template to brown the cheese in the shape of a cross.