Tastiest cheeseburger in the State

[mike4sigs]

I learned to Eat peanut butter on burgers several years ago when we ate at Scottys Brewhouse.
They called it a Shuman special.
Peanut butter,Fresh Jalapeono pepers slices and chedder cheese.
I add Sweet Baby Rays.

 

[foszoe]

I learned to Eat peanut butter on burgers several years ago when we ate at Scottys Brewhouse.
They called it a Shuman special.
Peanut butter,Fresh Jalapeono pepers slices and chedder cheese.
I add Sweet Baby Rays.

Try peanut butter stew. Fantastic

 

[tomcat13]

Decent Burger at Bubba's in Clarksville, but don't even Try to have a Conversation!
Loudest Place in Southern IN.
Guess I'm getting Old, but the Only Time we'll go there is when we can sit outside.

 

[cbhausen]

Nobody has mentioned Schoop’s… is this still a thing? I used to love to go there when I worked up in Warsaw.

 

[tv1217]

I initially read this title as "Tallest cheeseburger in the State" and just thought "What an odd metric"

 

[Aszerigan]

I learned to Eat peanut butter on burgers several years ago when we ate at Scottys Brewhouse.
They called it a Shuman special.
Peanut butter,Fresh Jalapeono pepers slices and chedder cheese.
I add Sweet Baby Rays.

ALWAYS got the Shuman Special. Shame they all closed down.

Grillerz in Ninevah (near Atterbury) has something similar - it's a burger with a fried egg, jalapeños and a Thai peanut sauce. Superb.

 

[snapping turtle]

I must like my burgers like the ladies. Cheap and thin. Nothing fancy on them just blue jeans a tee shirt and boots. (Well on the ladies.) Or ketchup mustard and relish.

The lemon drop in Anderson.

if I am going to pay for an expensive burger might as well go for burnt ends or some BBQ sandwiches. Just me but burgers are not designer duds just food for the masses.

 

[d.kaufman]

Nobody has mentioned Schoop’s… is this still a thing? I used to love to go there when I worked up in Warsaw.

Schoops is nowhere near a real cheeseburger.....

 

[Creedmoor]

I must like my burgers like the ladies. Cheap and thin. Nothing fancy on them just blue jeans a tee shirt and boots. (Well on the ladies.) Or ketchup mustard and relish.

The lemon drop in Anderson.

if I am going to pay for an expensive burger might as well go for burnt ends or some BBQ sandwiches. Just me but burgers are not designer duds just food for the masses.

My Thing 2 loves The Lemon Drop.

 

[LtScott14]

Wifey took me for a lunch at Longhorn Steak house. Have had their steaks were tasty, so ordered a basic cheeseburger, with bacon and ketchup. Very good burger! Dinner salad was fresh, croutons weren't like little bricks, frys too were very good.
I don't dress the burger too much, like to savor rhe beef taste.
Tried Chili's too. Buger was also very good, frys tasty, salad was little small, but fresh.
Longhorn gets my best vote though.

 

[BluePig]

Heinnie's in Elkhart.
Ask for the Claybaugh.

Fat Cam's on Garver Lake.
Double Fatty is a 1 lb burger.
And their postings are finger linking good.

 

[femurphy77]

My list in no particular order; Wendy's Baconator, BW3 All American Burger, wife's smashburger from the blackstone, Quarter Pounder w/cheese. Photogenic foofoo burgers that look "AMAZING" in the photos or touted by those best of lists or just over the top are typically a huge letdown and at a huge price.

5 Guys is usually our plan C or plan D for an unplanned lunch out, I don't understand all of the hype that surrounds them and their prices are WAY out of line for what you're getting. Some of the best burgers I've ever had usually come from some greasy spoon mom and pop place where you don't want to know what goes on in the kitchen.

 

[DoggyDaddy]

Some of the best burgers I've ever had usually come from some greasy spoon mom and pop place where

Probably only a few on here know about it, (@bcannon @Mgderf ) but I used to love Budge's Burgers when I lived in Lafayette.

Budges Drive In | Ice Cream Shop | Lafayette

Budges has been serving up Lafayette's Best Ice Cream Since 1942. Come see us for cool treats, fresh food, and a friendly staff.

www.budgesdrivein.com

Just a walk-up place that is seasonal, but good greasy burgers!

 

[ditcherman]

…Quarter Pounder w/cheese. Photogenic foofoo burgers that look "AMAZING" in the photos or touted by those best of lists or just over the top are typically a huge letdown and at a huge price.

Something here just doesn’t seem right here to me.

 

[femurphy77]

Something here just doesn’t seem right here to me.

The clowns burger is pretty static, never found one really bad or really good, all about the same. Just an excuse to get some of those fries.

 

[ditcherman]

The clowns burger is pretty static, never found one really bad or really good, all about the same. Just an excuse to get some of those fries.

It is consistent. That’s how they built their model so well. IMO if you don’t eat McD’s for a few years and then try one it’s just horrible, keeping it off of my list. But that’s just me.

 

[Mgderf]

Probably only a few on here know about it, (@bcannon @Mgderf ) but I used to love Budge's Burgers when I lived in Lafayette.

Budges Drive In | Ice Cream Shop | Lafayette

Budges has been serving up Lafayette's Best Ice Cream Since 1942. Come see us for cool treats, fresh food, and a friendly staff.

www.budgesdrivein.com

Just a walk-up place that is seasonal, but good greasy burgers!

Indeed.
Budge's is as much an icon in Lafayette as "Mutt-n-foam" (Dog-n-Suds).
Budge's is so busy during the summer hours that it takes too long from the average weekday lunch.
Great burgers, and fantastic malts.

 

[DoggyDaddy]

Indeed.
Budge's is as much an icon in Lafayette as "Mutt-n-foam" (Dog-n-Suds).
Budge's is so busy during the summer hours that it takes too long from the average weekday lunch.
Great burgers, and fantastic malts.

I used to live on Hartford, within walking distance. I keep meaning to get up there to meet bcannon for lunch sometime but haven't made it yet.

 

[Shadow01]

You would need the skills and jaw of Kamala to take a bite of it. Pass.

You can not go wrong at the Beef House. All the food is great, even the burgers. It is nice to live less than 20 minutes from it.

Beef House Restaurant

Welcome to the Beef House Restaurant! We have named our restaurant THE BEEF HOUSE because we are serving high choice aged beef at moderate prices. We believe that most people dinning out will enjoy our steaks cooked over hardwood briquets on our open hearth charcoal broiler. In sight before...

beefhouserolls.com

No where near as good as they were 20 years ago. Covid lead them down a path that has run a lot of their business off. Let alone all the illegals in the kitchen…

 

[indiucky]

Hinkle's in Madison.....