Talk me out of buying a FNX 9

[submitbytyping]

I'm interested in a 9mm in SA/DA with hi-cap for in the woods plinking.

I've considered most of the options out there but to give you an idea of my thoughts: my back-up plan is either the CZ P07 or forgoing the whole plastic thing and getting a very affordable S&W 5906.

I'm very ok with safety devices on my handgun. The additional money for the SIGs or HKs doesn't seem worth it to me, but they are still under consideration if I thought it was worth the additional cost.

Other then just shoot them all and buy the one you like, anyone have any advice? Thanks in advance!

 

[kawtech87]

I had an FNX-9 and didnt care much for it. It didnt fit me very good, the balance felt weird (top heavy), and the safety/decocker felt flimsy. Also there just isnt much out there for them and finding accesories proved nearly impossible.

If I were you I would look into a CZ-75 compact if you want a safety or a P-01 if you want a decocker. I like the P-07 but Im not much for plastic guns. Or you could look into a good used Sig like a police trade in for about the same price.

 

[skydelta34]

You'll shoot your eye out.

Oh sorry, that is a Daisy Red Ryder.

 

[joshualee49]

You can't go wrong with a 5906\6906 S&W series. Tried and true and very affordable.

I had an FNP-9 that I loved. No experience with the FNX but FN is also a very solid firearm.

$ for $ I would go with the S&W for general plinking. You can buy quite a bit of 9mm ammo to shoot with the $ you save over an FN.

S&W has your decocker and mag disconnect. Also has double strike capability which is nice IMO. My FN had the decocker but no mag disconnect. Not sure about the FNX variants...

 

[Robert Richardson]

OK, don't buy one.

 

[dom1104]

FN guns are the worst of the current polymer crop.

 

[WebSnyper]

I'd think, but don't know that accessories (holsters, etc) would be a pain to find.

Do you have a gun you carry now? Do you intend to potentially carry this gun at some point?

 

[TopDog]

FN guns are the worst of the current polymer crop.

I totally disagree with that statement. Exactly what do you base that statement on? You think that Hi Points and Taurus are better guns than the FNH line?

I only own a FNP9 but its high quality, reliable, very accurate and a pleasure to shoot. There are not that many polymer counterparts out there that I would take in trade for it.

 

[handgun]

Hang it up dont buy one.. buy your self a kahr T9.. fun for plinking and the safety is you... seriously note though i have enjoyed shooting FN products.. however if you want a true plinker go witg the fn p90 you will be glad you did... nifty gun

I dont care for "safetys" one more thing to fumble with in the moment of true need..

 

[HeadlessRoland]

Do it. You know you want it. You can afford it. It's nice. You want it. Buy it.

 

[Bumsi]

They shoot great but the mags are expensive

 

[netsecurity]

I'll talk you out of it, because I talked myself out of it!

#1 problem: Magazine cannot be simply slammed in, it falls out! Google it...
#2 issue: High bore axis, does it have more recoil than M&P? Most likely, unless it is heavier I suspect.
#3 issue: It is tall and large, so difficult to conceal.
#4 issue: Difficult to find holsters and accessories.
#5 issue: Over $500.


On the bright side, it is reported to be extremely accurate, have a great trigger and would make a great range gun. I buy my guns for self defense though, and practice at the range with the same weapons. M&P and Glock don't have the deficiencies above, and M&P's are a lot cheaper. I also second the advice to checkout CZ's.

 

[Birds Away]

I had an FNX-9 and didnt care much for it. It didnt fit me very good, the balance felt weird (top heavy), and the safety/decocker felt flimsy. Also there just isnt much out there for them and finding accesories proved nearly impossible.

If I were you I would look into a CZ-75 compact if you want a safety or a P-01 if you want a decocker. I like the P-07 but Im not much for plastic guns. Or you could look into a good used Sig like a police trade in for about the same price.

+! I had the same experience with the FN. I would second the recommendation for the CZs and add that if you don't like the rail on the P01 take a look at the 75 PCR compact.

 

[submitbytyping]

well you guys did it. Thanks to everyone who took the time to post - your opinions were appreciated. I opted for a 5906 from CDNN. They have VG-Excellents listed on the front page of their new (2012-3) catalog. Got an extra mag (30$) and with shipping (20) ran me about 400. I pick it up next week.

 

[davedolli]

You will like your new to you 5906, they are great pistols and built like a tank. I had to get use to mine with the double/single action and mag disconnect.

Dave

 

[Dsgnr_81]

FN guns are the worst of the current polymer crop.

I'd like to see what evidence you've got to support that statement.

I've had good experience with FN firearms for years. I currently own an FNX-9. Got it for a reasonable price, and I like it. I had to adjust my shooting grip ever so slightly to adjust for the safety lever. Other than that, it's more accurate than I am, it goes bang each time [post break in of 200 rounds], and it's stylish. Decisions yours to make though. If you would like to try it out, I'm planning on shooting tomorrow afternoon south of Anderson.

 

[OLDSMITH]

submitbytyping, I think you made a very good choice. Keep us updated on how the 5906 shoots and your thoughts on it.

 

[nick89302]

You'll be happy with the 5906. Smith autos are underrated by many simply because they aren't the newest sexiest gun in the case.

Not that the FNX would've been a bad choice, but you won't be disappointed in the S&W.

 

[maxmayhem]

I have heard of some frame separation with some of the FN firearms...i really like the action of the firearm but cant ever pull the trigger on a purchase (pun intended) ....i tried to find a pic of the firearms they were showing that had the widened gap between the frame and slide but cant seem to find it...i did find this thread though...also i am not talking you out of getting it because you asked...i have considered buying it/trading for it but decided against it despite the positive aspects about the firearrm which are nice trigger ..like the double action...i think it would possibly be fine but i dont like taking 4-500 chances on things...get a xd or glock or a beretta storm pistol or a sig (not p250) just my 2 cents ..say im wrong or right ..just my opinion
Yet Another Problem Surfaces With The FNP9/40 Pistol Series: Slide Gouging - The Firing Line Forums

 

[Roscoe38]

I'm interested in a 9mm in SA/DA with hi-cap for in the woods plinking.

I've considered most of the options out there but to give you an idea of my thoughts: my back-up plan is either the CZ P07 or forgoing the whole plastic thing and getting a very affordable S&W 5906.

I'm very ok with safety devices on my handgun. The additional money for the SIGs or HKs doesn't seem worth it to me, but they are still under consideration if I thought it was worth the additional cost.

Other then just shoot them all and buy the one you like, anyone have any advice? Thanks in advance!

Either one would be a great piece. I've owned each of them. No problems just great shooters. I just can't make myself stay with one gun for extended lengths of time. Sometimes I really regret selling either one of them. Replacement would be a lot more costly.