I have one of the old Buck Buckmaster 184 with the sheath and 1 original pin. I have been considering selling it off but can't get a good idea of what they would be worth. I have found prices all over the place. Any suggestions for a good starting point?
I have one of the early ones with both pins and the compass even. The price depends on the vintage. I have seen them on Ebay fetch $300 or more. The more accessories that survived with it the better. The Buck-184 Buckmaster - The peak of survival knives! has info on them plus links to the bay for price checks.