The only difference I can think of is that i cleaned about 2/3 of a five gallon bucket of 9mm in batches and then put it in a bucket under my bench and have been using that brass. Probably cleaned it 5-6 months ago.
Could the the polish maybe get sticky sitting that long?
I would not think that would be a problem unless you had some noticable corrosion. At the same time, my habit is not cleaning the brass at all or cleaning it shortly before a loading session. Maybe try running the next batch through the tumbler for maybe 20 minutes and see if that takes care of the problem.
I cannot think of anything else. Let us know what you come up with.