Sabers ?

[jeremy]

I am looking into replacing my Cavalry Saber with something of quality, as opposed to the $40.00 one I currently have.

What exactly is the "British Proof Test"?
Any recommendations?

 

[4sarge]

The British Proof Test for Swords

The British Proof Test was created to ensure soldiers would only be issued weapons of the highest quality. For a sword to pass the entire British Proof Test, it must pass each of these six tests:


Test 1: Hit the cutting edge of the sword or saber HARD on a heavy wood block. The blade must remain straight and the handle, guard and tang, etc, must all remain rigidly in place with no bending, loosening, rattling, twisting, or turning at all or the sword fails.

Test 2: Hit the back of the blade HARD on a heavy wood block. The blade must remain straight and true and the handle, guard and tang, etc, must all remain rigidly in place with not bending, loosening, rattling, twisting, or turning at all or the sword fails.

Test 3: Hit the flat side of the blade hard on the wooden block and the blade must not bend. The blade must recover and come back truly straight. If it bends or takes a “set” other than straight it must be rejected.

Test 4: Same as test #3 except the other side of the blade is to be struck.

Test 5: Set the point of the sword on a heavy wood block and flex the blade 5” to the left. It must recover to truly straight. If the blade bends or takes a set other than straight I must be rejected.

Test 6: Same as #5 but the blade is flexed to the right.


Decent Review Cold Steels British Military Swords

 

[Zephri]

I've found this is a great site to learn about budget swords ($100-$300 range) Swords for Sale - A Buyers Guide. They also have a fourm, so if you need to ask any questions they can answer them better than most of us could.

btw: Here's a direct link to the article you might want to read Cold Steels British Military Swords

 

[jeremy]

I think I have found the replacement for my El Cheapo 1860 U.S. Heavy Cavalry Saber. I am going with a Cold Steel 1860 U.S. Heavy Cavalry Saber. It appears to actually be a serviceable saber.

Now to find a replacement for my El Cheapo M1840 NCO Sword.

 

[CarmelHP]

My beef with Cold Steel is that I read that they are all made in India or China. That turned me right off. I'n only interested if it's a quality steel from a Western country.

 

[jeremy]

Is there a sword sutler in the state?

 

[Uralguy]

1917 Cutlass

Just ordered a 1917 Cutlass. Pretty good discussion on the 1919A4 site.

Swords if you have to ever use one. - 1919a4 forums

 

[CarmelHP]

Just ordered a 1917 Cutlass. Pretty good discussion on the 1919A4 site.

Swords if you have to ever use one. - 1919a4 forums

I like.

 

[cce1302]

Here's the sword I have. I'd imagine they make a cavalry saber as well. The quality is A++ Excellent.
Premium Marine Sword: US Officer by Marlow White

 

[CarmelHP]

I'm assuming that has a ceremonial edge though, correct?

 

[cce1302]

I'm assuming that has a ceremonial edge though, correct?

It did when I bought it.




It still does. Only good for cutting cake.

 

[jeremy]

Here's the sword I have. I'd imagine they make a cavalry saber as well. The quality is A++ Excellent.
Premium Marine Sword: US Officer by Marlow White

I have to purchase both an 1840 sword and an 1860 saber. The 1840 will be from Marlow it looks like a beautiful piece. I think I like the 1860 from Cold Steel better though.

 

[Eisman]

MY PICK

Not a Sabre but this is my pick for a long knife

 

[mfrobert]

The british like most other armies wanted something that would stand the test of time...There are several makers of sabers out there that will suit your need, most of who have already been mentioned. Best of luck in your search!

Matt